The Next Big Market for Insurance Chris Mason, Senior Marketing Associate | Nov 02, 2017


Soft market, increased competition, tech disruption – we’ve heard the bad news before. The good news? The next green pasture for insurers is beginning to blossom. In April of 2016 millennials surpassed baby boomers as the nation’s largest living generation at around 86 million strong.1 The first wave of millennials are already prime targets – they’re employed, managing debt well, saving correctly, and are reaching the prime purchasing age of 35.

As baby boomers retire, millennials will account for an increasing share of the workforce. Today that number stands at 30% and it’s expected to reach 75% by 20252. And this is a generation with growing influence. According to The Millennial Leadership Study, 91 percent of millennials aspire to be leaders, and they’re stepping into those roles even when they don’t feel ready.3 As decision-makers, millennials will gain the power of the corporate dollar and will have a greater say over commercial insurance purchases.

So how do insurers capture this generational that’s primed and ready to purchase?4 As we’ve covered in a previous post, millennial buying patterns are all but set in stone. That makes the strategic intersection between millennials and insurance distribution channels all that more important.

How Millennials Buy: The Information Generation

Buying practices learned through their youth will ultimately bleed into millennials’ decisions when it is time to buy insurance. At the time of a purchasing decision, millennials are “infosumers”, avid researchers who use every tool available to make the best decision on a product or brand. Growing up with Google has its perks.

Speaking from personal experience, almost every major buying decision has boiled down to research. All my purchases start with an inquiry online, generally with assistance from knowledge experts. My main sources include trusted friends who know a certain product, online research, social media reviews, or a vetted knowledge expert.  

We buy socially, on the expert information given to us by others. We crowdsource reviews on social media.4 When I buy a television, for example, the only reason I would walk into Best Buy would be to talk to someone who can help me sort through all the options available, and even then, I still seek out a friend who has been through the experience before.

Selling to Millennials: Flexibility and Knowledge

Insurers who can respond to millennials’ need to be informed consumers will be well-positioned when millennials come calling. Offering diverse capabilities online, with expert advice, will also be crucial to long term success.

So, what are some steps for insurers who want to position themselves to capture business from what will be the largest buying cohort in America?

  1. Flexible Purchasing Channels: Millennials like the option to purchase things, such as insurance, through various channels. This doesn’t mean you must integrate an app into your Facebook page, but it does mean you should have a variety of ways to purchase policies and products. Straight-through processing online should be supplemented by expert advice for more complex policies. Make it easy to connect with an agent through your website while also having an online portal to process less underwriting-intensive policies. Don’t just do one well, do both.

  2. The “Back-Office” Agent: There has been a lot of talk about the changing role of the agent. The average millennial doesn’t know much about insurance, so having the ability to quickly connect with a knowledge expert is still vital, and there are relatively inexpensive ways to deliver this. Online chat, for example, makes it fast and easy to connect prospective millennial buyers with an agent. This generation likes to know what they are getting before they buy it – in  plain English – and an agent can help greatly.

  3. The Insurance Knowledge Expert: Positioning your company as a team of insurance experts can elevate your status in the eyes of millennial buyers. Sharing your knowledge through blogging is an easy, cost-effective way to accomplish this, but steer clear of overly persuasive and sales-like writing. This will ultimately turn this generation away. Millennials want to become educated consumers, and explaining the differences between BOP policies, or the various limits in car coverages, for example, will help millennials understand what they’re buying. When it comes time to purchase they are more likely to choose the knowledge expert who helped to educate them.

Millennials are fast becoming the most significant purchasing force our country has seen – and they’re different. The sooner you understand and act on their buying preference, the greater chance you’ll have of selling to the next big market for insurance.



Chris Mason is, by his own admission, a millennial as well as a Senior Marketing Associate for Instec. He has 5+ years of marketing experience, and a unique view of the insurance marketplace as a recent graduate of Marquette University in 2012. He volunteers with the IASA, working as a Lead Producer for webinars put on by their eLearning Committee.